‘The Secret History’ by Donna Tartt


‘I suppose at one time in my life I might have had any number of stories, but now there is no other. This is the only story I will ever be able to tell’.

The Secret History, Donna Tartt, Pg.2

I started reading Donna Tartt’s first novel, The Secret History, immediately after I finished The Goldfinch as part of the Baileys Prize shortlist challenge I set myself over a month ago now (though, with Angela Carter week and a couple of review copies to read, I have only now had the chance to reflect on it). I am completely addicted to Tartt’s miniaturist style and the way her words can fully immerse me into the story, like I am there in the midst of the action, witnessing the awful (and they are always awful) events that are about to transpire. She is a master of descriptive writing, just like Charles Dickens – her literary idol, and her words can literally paint a clear and vivid picture:

‘The very colours of the place seeped into my blood: just as Hampden, in subsequent years, would always present itself immediately to my imagination in a confused whirl of white and green and red, so the country house first appeared as a glorious blur of watercolours, of ivory and lapis blue, chestnut and burnt orange and gold, separating only gradually into the boundaries of remembered objects: the house, the sky, the maple trees. But even that day, there on the porch, with Charles beside me and the smell of wood smoke in the air, it had the quality of a memory; there it was, before my eyes, and yet too beautiful to believe’.

The Secret History, Donna Tartt, Pg.113

I have also heard all about the cult following surrounding Tartt’s debut so I couldn’t wait to start reading The Secret History. I was not disappointed. Tartt, like some of my favourite contemporary authors – Margaret Atwood, Marilynne Robinson, Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie – makes me feel safe and secure in the knowledge that I am reading brilliant literature. She knows how to write instant classics that will stand the test of time and The Secret History is a testament to this. After 22 years its legacy and its ‘cult’ following still remains stronger than ever.

The Secret History begins, much like how The Goldfinch does, with the revelation of a terrible event that has rocked the protagonists’ world. In the Prologue we are told about the death of a friend, Bunny, or, more specifically, his premeditated murder: ‘the loose rocks, the body at the bottom of the ravine with a clean break in the neck, and the muddy skidmarks of dug-in heels pointing the way down’ (pg.1). Richard Papen’s first person narrative reveals everything – the facts of the climactic event that will haunt his life – in these first few pages. Nothing is left to the imagination. Yet, as the narrative jumps back to the ‘beginning’, in an effort to explain how the actions of this eccentric group of students led to murder, Tartt manages to grip my imagination and create a story steeped in suspense. At over 600 pages long, it is no short read, but I found Tartt’s style so beautiful and effortless that I raced through the pages with the paradoxical feeling of wanting to know what happened and how, but also not wanting the story to end.

‘It is easy to see things in retrospect. But I was ignorant then of everything but my own happiness, and I don’t know what else to say except that life itself seemed very magical in those days: a web of symbol, coincidence, premonition, omen’.

The Secret History, Donna Tartt, Pg.102

Set in the beautiful New England landscape, The Secret History tells the tale of a close-knit group of Classics students headed by their eccentric professor, Julian. Comprised of five affluent and extremely intelligent individuals – Henry, Francis, Charles, Camilla and Bunny – the protagonist, Richard, arrives in Hampden as the Californian outsider. Intrigued by this mysterious clique, Richard attempts to fit in by painfully trying to hide his relatively poor upbringing. Going to extremes to cover the fact that he has to work in order to sustain any semblance of privilege, Richard eventually finds himself indebted to Henry – the unquestionable ring leader. By far the wealthiest, most intelligent and impossible to deduce, Henry is, by all appearances, a sincere and honest guy. However, there are many small, niggling instances Richard glosses over that would suggest that his early days as part of this exclusive club are anything but perfect. Despite fighting his way onto Julian’s rigid Classics major, where the professor believes that ‘having a great diversity of teachers is harmful and confusing for a young mind, in the same way I believe that it is better to know one book intimately than a hundred superficially’, and alienating himself from the rest of his year, Richard isn’t any closer to being in on the secrets of these five intriguing individuals.

‘It was one of those mysterious oppressive days we sometimes had at Hampden, where the mountains that lowered at the horizon were swallowed up in fog and the world seemed light and empty, dangerous somehow’.

The Secret History, Donna Tartt, Pg.413

Fraught with suspense, in the heart of a romanticised, idyllic landscape of academia, Donna Tartt’s The Secret History gripped me to the core and left me gasping for air. The cult-like, though fully-fleshed-out, existence of the main characters is seductive to the point where I, like Richard, wanted to be a part of their clique. As Alice from ofBooks writes in her recent review: ‘By the end of the novel even I felt guilty, for hating Bunny, for accepting murder’. I felt exactly the same – almost ashamed that I never questioned Henry or the group’s actions, no matter how much they escalated from normality to madness. From a story of humble beginnings, of a person just trying to fit in – a story we can all relate to in one way or another – Tartt sweeps us up and drives us to the brink of the ravine, not just witnessing, but also complicit in, the murder of a friend.

‘It’s funny, but thinking back on it now, I realise that this particular point in time, as I stood there blinking in the deserted hall, was the one point at which I might have chosen to do something very different from what I actually did. But of course I didn’t see this crucial moment then for what it was; I suppose we never do. Instead, I only yawned, and shook myself from the momentary daze that had come upon me, and went on my way down the stairs’.

The Secret History, Donna Tartt, Pg.223

As Richard states, in hindsight things may have turned out differently. But that is the wonderfully ironic nature of hindsight – you only recognise moments that can change the direction of your life in retrospect. During the moment you may not see any other options available to you, which is certainly the case for Richard as he becomes further and further embroiled in the inevitable madness that ensues.

Donna Tartt’s debut novel, The Secret History, is a stunningly heady and nostalgic account of university life where reinvention, transformation and enlightenment are all possible. Where, in an idyllic world, anything is possible. I was left feeling in awe of such a powerful and haunting tale. It is easily one of the best novels I have read.


37 Replies to “‘The Secret History’ by Donna Tartt”

  1. What a beautiful review! The book has been on my radar for a while already, and I think now I will read it before The Goldfinch.
    (And thanks for following me on Twitter. I guess now I have to start using it. 🙂 )

    1. Your welcome! I’m still trying to get to grips with Twitter myself. Thank you, it took me ages to try and write this review I don’t think words can do justice to such a great novel.

  2. Great review. I’ve had this sitting at home for a while; think I’ll have to try it sooner rather than later!

    1. Oh no! I am a bit apprehensive about starting The Little Friend. I think I will have to give it a considerable amount of time before I attempt it!

  3. Ok, I knew I wanted to read this sometime, but now I feel like my life won’t be complete until I do. You are on a roll! I’ve got three of your recent reviews bookmarked. 🙂 I love what you said about feeling safe and secure knowing you are reading brilliant literature.

  4. Wonderful review! I haven’t read any of Donna Tartt’s novels yet, but they’re on my list. After your review, I want to read The Secret History as soon as possible!

    1. You are in for a treat (hopefully)! I hadn’t read any of Donna Tartt’s books before this year, now I only have one left to go!

  5. Amazing review of an amazing novel! I read this a month or so ago after loving The Goldfinch to pieces, and I completely agree, it was amazing and hard to believe it was her FIRST novel! I felt like I went to Hampden myself!

  6. Fabulous review! You’ve reminded me of why i loved this novel. Since I read and really disliked The Goldfinch I’ve been wondering how I would feel if I revisited The Secret History – I think you’ve reassured me that I would still find it as special as I did first time round.

    1. You disliked The Goldfinch!!! I guess if I had read The Goldfinch after The Secret History it would have paled in comparison. Now I’m a bit worried about reading The Little Friend.

      1. I fear I didn’t much like The Little Friend either. At least, I wasn’t blown away by it the way I was by The Secret History anyway. And The Goldfinch just didn’t do it for me at all – sorry! But I know I’m in the minority on that one…

      2. I have heard a few people say they didn’t like The Little Friend – I think I will wait a while to read it (once the experience of reading The Secret History fades a little bit). I don’t know how you can top a book like The Secret History though, it was incredible.

      3. Yes, I always rather pity authors whose first book is so wonderful – everything they later do will inevitably be compared. I suspect my reaction to her later books would have been less critical if I’d never read this one.

  7. This is a fantastic review Yasmine. The Secret History is one of my favourite and most reread books. I read it while doing my Masters in a new city and that feeling of reinvention and self discovery really resonated with me. I liked The Little Friend as well and am yet to read The Goldfinch, but I’m looking forward to it.

    1. Thank you! I’m glad to hear you liked The Little Friend, I have heard a few people say they didn’t like it that much and I wonder how it compares to The Secret History. I really enjoyed The Goldfinch, I hope you do too!

  8. “safe and secure in the knowledge that I am reading brilliant literature” – that’s such a good description!

    The Secret History is a long ago read for me. I remember being amazed it was so readable and transported me both to another physical world and the weird closed world of the friends. I equated “good literature” with hard work and was quite puzzled with what I found.

    I love your closing paragraph too.

    1. Thank you, it took me far too long to write my thoughts up on The Secret History, though after a month my memories of the novel haven’t waned at all (which usually happens!). I was surprised, too, by how accessible it was. I was daunted at first by the descriptions of a group of Classics students studying Ancient Greek, etc, but it was very readable even if you don’t have much knowledge on Greek philosophers or Bacchanal rituals (like me).

  9. Great review. I just got a copy of this for my birthday and cannot wait to read it. I just adored The Goldfinch.

    1. I wish I was reading it for the first time all over again! I hope you enjoy it! I loved The Goldfinch as well.

    1. It is such a brilliant book. I will definitely be rereading it again for sure. I just hope it lives up to the first reading!

  10. Wondrous review, this is exactly how I felt.

    “The cult-like, though fully-fleshed-out, existence of the main characters is seductive to the point where I, like Richard, wanted to be a part of their clique.”
    I’m still, almost, upset I’m not in it now. I’m upset the book is over and I – like Richard – am ambling through my life. It’s as if the murder is an unfortunate side affect or blemish on an otherwise appealing intellectual secret society.

    The passage you’ve quoted from page 102, I think that is how I felt post reading the book.

    1. Thank you! Haha it really did seem as if the murder was just an unfortunate side effect. I don’t know how Tartt manages to make this little clique so appealing when there is so much wrong with them!

  11. I love this review. I loved the book when I read it and now I’m so glad you brought it back. I’m tempted to pick it up. I’ve got The Little Friend but never dared reading it. Maybe I’ll read The Goldfinch first.
    The Secret History is one of the bets books I’ve read as well.

  12. I think this is actually a much better book than ‘The Goldfinch’ – much more tightly written. For me ‘The Goldfinch’ is too baggy and would have benefitted from a good edit.

    1. I really enjoyed The Goldfinch but I did prefer The Secret History. I see what you mean about The Goldfinch being too baggy, though it didn’t hinder my enjoyment of it.

  13. After reading and thoroughly enjoying Tartt’s ‘The Goldfinch’ I have earmarked her other novels as a must read. But trying to squeeze them into my TBR and other books I read for my degree it is always going to a difficult thing to do. An engaging review and a very bold statement at the end; “It is easily one of the best novels I have read.”

    1. When you get the chance you should definitely read it. I loved The Goldfinch but found The Secret History even better!

  14. Agreed! I just read “Secret History” earlier this year. After I read it, I couldn’t believe I had waited so long to do so. What a fabulous book! I’m looking forward to reading “The Goldfinch,’ too.

    1. I felt exactly the same when I read it! It’s such an amazing book and Donna Tartt is an incredible writer. I hope you enjoy The Goldfinch!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s